sonos, google lawsuit

NP: But the labels dont care; they just want to get paid. In a perfect world, if Ive built the team in such a way that I have leaders that are all better than me in their particular area, what Im doing is trying to support them, guide them, and be a sounding board in terms of making those decisions. Jos Castaeda, a Google spokesman, said that the company disagreed with the ruling, but that it would work to ensure there was no disruption in the products used by customers or its ability to sell or import devices. Most of the commentary during the hearing focused on dominant market giants Amazon and Google, with. The case concerns technology around the latter's smart speaker products. Theres still nothing like that for certain conversations, discussions, debates just having dinner and lunch and breaking bread together. Sonos filed a patent infringement lawsuit against Google at the beginning of last year. That was it. Every one of them survived, five for five. One is strategy. Theres a lot of room for us to seize more opportunities. This modification directly results from the ITC's decision, as the group found the feature violated a patent from Sonos. Its pretty collaborative in terms of working closely, probably because Im Canadian. PS: Id take you back to my point about the decision to sue Google and take this path. Google vs Sonos: Google says it owns the technology at the centre of the lawsuit. How does that work? Sonos was a pioneer in home speakers that stream music or podcasts from smartphones and that can be wirelessly networked together to play songs in different rooms. You said two products a year. Most of our homes listen to both a radio service and then have an on-demand streaming service as well. It was a combination of expert judgment that led me to the strong conviction that our patents were going to survive an unbelievable onslaught by Google. It reflects on us, of course, just like any of the other platforms choices reflect on the company. Lets pick out one decision because I think it will be illuminating in a variety of ways. If theres not change, if these lawsuits dont work and get Google to the table appropriately, are these existential issues for you? With each extension of its business, Google muscles onto the turf of smaller companies that did not expect to tangle with a behemoth with seemingly unlimited resources. You will see stations there that are all about Sonos whether its the jazz station that Kareem Abdul-Jabbar is doing or Erykah Badu. Sonos'. I started here at the beginning of 2019. So were going to hold them to account in court until theyre willing to come to the table and give us a fair royalty. NP: Do you think these issues are existential for Sonos or companies like Sonos? NP: They had a system called HEOS you kind of knew those were good. Youve won with them. So they werent surprised when I came to them, because they knew I felt like it wasnt heading in a constructive direction. Great to talk to you again. Lets not forget why were doing this at the end of the day. What we really wanted to do was just reinvent it and learn and see what we could learn because I do think being in the space as well helps us better serve and direct our partners. I think these are fundamental inventions that solved problems that nobody else had been able to solve before. The company will not be allowed to import products that infringe on Sonos patents, including smart speakers, video streaming devices, and some computers and phones. Are you making headphones? Theyre just charging the same rights to everyone. This is our leverage to go into these conversations and get Google, or whoever, to come to the table in a more fair way. Thats the strategy. You used to be a person, man. PS: I try to know all the names and the backgrounds as much as I can. The pace of it all is so fast in this day and age just making sure that were going to continue to stay ahead of the curve. EL: I just happened to mention that one, but kidding aside, that is a major problem this issue of cross-subsidization and whether that ought to be considered anti-competitive. By the way, they think of themselves as inventors in and of themselves some of my lawyers are actually inventors on patents. This lawsuit has been brewing for two years, and the fact that Google wasn't prepared for workarounds on these issues when possible, given all that time, doesn't seem acceptable. You have companies who will just buy up patent portfolios and sue people to make a quick buck. Prior to the pandemic, we had 15% working from home. How have you changed that structure? I think one of key jobs for a CEO is to determine when you actually need to make a decision on something. Weve been able to pick up some talent we never wouldve been able to before. How many people do you have? NP: Whereas Apple can just wave away a zero margin. 3. Alphabet Inc.'s Google LLC filed two lawsuits Monday in a California federal court, alleging in one that Sonos Inc.'s audio players with a voice-control feature infringe three patents, and in the other that they infringe four different patents, expanding an already heated battle over royalties for various technologies.. We did feel it was important at least to plug into that process and understand what was going on. I dont know that you can just offer those kinds of things for free, necessarily. Sonos has recently been in the spotlight for its financial troubles during the covid-19 pandemic and for its feud with Google, which has seen the two companies trading one lawsuit for. EL: We havent tried to make a case on cross-subsidization, frankly, because the law on that topic, on predatory pricing over the years the standards become pretty much impossible to meet. Youre in that situation. The proofs right there in the testimony. I would say competition laws are maybe not as heated as other elements of our politics, but the issue still is not necessarily totally bipartisan. Sonos is in the middle of a few big policy issues in tech: the ever-present patent litigation discussion that happens, and antitrust law. But it does seem like once you make that decision, it is inevitable that you will employ and spend more resources on software than hardware. Its really the Sonos story that does the work for us. Well do roughly $2 billion in sales this year. But that is a pretty big shift in terms of what were doing from work from home. EL: Its somewhere in the middle. The two companies were unable to reach an agreement. This is a fun one. Its really us, as well, sharing with our customers our perspective on the world, to some degree, and the kind of artists that we think should be celebrated. Its largely a commoditized circumstance, but we have some licensing folks who get into it with the major labels, but its not been a source of any contention or anything like that. Sonos accused. With Chromecast, you can also control apps, such as Netflix, YouTube, and Starz. The lawsuit is part of a cross-jurisdictional battle between the two companies which spans Canada, the U.S., France, the Netherlands, and Germany. Weve been doing two new products a year. "With its update," the lawsuit states, "Sonos acted by force to limit consumer choice instead of competing lawfully, based upon the quality and servicing of its devices." The plaintiff says that after both of his CR100 controllers failed, the devices displayed a message directing him to www.sonos.com/cr100, which states, in part: I actually brought in a second firm to make an independent assessment so that I made sure we werent just drinking our own Kool-Aid about the strength of our portfolio. EL: I dont know why Patrick would listen to that any more than anything else hes got his own mind about what he wants to say. has definitively validated the five Sonos patents at issue in this case and ruled unequivocally that Google infringes all five, Eddie Lazarus, the chief legal officer at Sonos, said in a statement. Weve had China in the mix and Malaysia now as well. We appreciate that the I.T.C. Weve taken the shackles off of where our offices are located and were picking up great talent to add to our already amazing team. They understand our patent portfolio at an incredibly deep level. Remember, the most important thing for us is being open and supporting all the services that matter to our customers. Listen to Decoder, a show hosted by The Verges Nilay Patel about big ideas and other problems. Thats pending in federal court now because its not really just about that original conception. Its invented a lot of stuff. You can go all the way back to the US Constitution. In a lawsuit, Sonos accused Google of stealing proprietary information obtained when the two companies previously partnered on Google's now-discontinued Play Music service. "Due to a recent legal ruling we're making some changes to how you set up your devices, and the Speaker Group functionality will work moving . We had some conversations internally of how it fits with everybody else out there, but its something Ive felt like we needed to do to keep growing as an organization and that it would be complementary to the other services offered. The business model in the early days was very simple: You made some speakers. NP: Thats actually interesting because you litigated some of those patents before with Denon. Google's allegations came in response to a lawsuit Sonos filed in January 2020. They actually put a price on Google Photos! A podcast from The Verge about big ideas and other problems. Once you commit to that mindset the magic is the software your software cost tends to grow. I just havent seen the technology yet applied in a way that theres an aha! moment for consumers. This is not just a radio music licensing question. We build a product that people love and are proud to share with their friends and family. Janko Roettgers. A U.S. trade agency is taking a closer look at Sonos Inc. 's claims that Alphabet Inc. 's Google infringes patents for home audio systems and is considering whether to shut some Google smart . I tried to address that constructively and then said, Look, were in a position because of the business weve built and the innovation we continue to drive, that we can take this. We think thats horrible for the consuming public. Between partnerships, thinking about blockchain, looking at the products, and dealing with me asking for Atmos support I take up a lot of your minutes how do you say, Im going to go spend my time on this. They rarely make money for any company, unless you run a law firm. The breach-of-contract accusation over the software adds a new wrinkle to what's already become an ugly legal. We have a long conversation on innovation and how much we need to be investing to continue to drive our business and grow our business. Over the last 20 years, you and I have seen that there are always lots of technologies and lots of philosophical discussions about what they might do, but when it comes down to brass tacks, what problems are we actually solving? That leads how I work with the team, how I think about the industry, and who I engage with outside of Sonos. Lets start all the way back at the beginning. We just think the self-evident nature of this, once people understand whats really happening, is going to carry the day. It then followed with another lawsuit in September 2020, alleging that Google's entire. EL: I dont know that it really is political activism on our part. I mean, we even published our patents publicly. NP: At the end of the day, you need to have deals with Apple, Spotify, Google, and whoever else. And ignoring. For one of the largest companies in the history of the world to do that is wrong. Sometimes you also need to think about which decisions need to get made when. We do it in a unique way. NP: Its way more intense than when the PR person is there. It was an area where I felt it would be complementary to what a lot of our partners are doing as opposed to anything that is really competitive. They include Google Home smart speakers, Pixel phones and computers, and the Chromecast streaming video device. Eddie Lazarus, the chief legal officer at Sonos, told The New York Times, "We appreciate that the ITC has definitively validated the five Sonos patents at. Whats your process? They drove out a business and then whoa, imagine that! Patrick Spence you are the CEO of Sonos. You have all these partners that you have to tend to that make the product work, but now youre competing with them. Its easy to see on a spreadsheet that investing in engineers and hardware tooling will pay off and generate revenue if you get it right. Otherwise, its just me. We have these amazing people inside the organization. 2023 Vox Media, LLC. The decision means that Google's smart speakers and other smart home tech. We made it very product-centric in terms of what were doing. Spotify or Sonos maybe cant. And its the right thing for tech more generally to take them on.. Its easier in hindsight to understand that a company has been working on all of these great things. I would start with trying to build Sonos for decades to come and working back from there. Has it made it better? Its a big claim, and I wanted to push on it a little and push on when that kind of lobbying effort becomes important enough to spend time on. How are we working as a team together? NP: Patrick, you mentioned Sonos has been around for a long time. Eddie, I dont know if you want to add anything. EL: Its certainly true that patent litigation has been abused at times. People have the same complaints about Amazon. NP: See, you start doing the lawsuits. How was Sonos structured when you took over? I would go acquire some MP3s from wherever I acquired them from ideally legally. I think that we should be paid for our inventions. Fundamentally, their job is to help decide whether to keep me on or fire me, and then be a sounding board on strategic questions. As The New York Times notes, the products affected. Back in January of last year, a smart speaker company by the name of Sonos initiated a lawsuit against Google, accusing it of stealing original features for its own speakers. In return, Sonos filed another lawsuit in western Texas claiming Google violated another five patents. Do you have standards and practices for your radio station? EL: I think thats just wrong. The actual lawyer is right there. PS: From everything Ive seen, I think that is right. And we won on infringement on all five as well. These are all fundamentally software patents. They will just keep the same price, because their lossless is cheaper than Amazons lossless or whoever else. Seven more patents are allegedly infringed upon according to these latest cases. We came to the end of the road on constructive conversations. PS: We remain open to trying to solve this in other ways. Related: The Best Sonos Speakers for Your Home Sonos said that Google infringed on several of its patents, including technology used to: Set up new devices After Google lost an earlier patent case over speaker volume controls, Google is now suing Sonos over voice control technology. Thats why we felt it was important to tell our story. Smart-speaker firm Sonos has won a major legal battle against Google over patents it said the firm had infringed. But it can't reward damages. NP: You mentioned the pandemic and, obviously, remote work. The ruling follows a lawsuit Sonos filed in January 2020, alleging that the search giant stole its technology when the two companies partnered to make sure Google's music service worked well with . EL: Theres not one way to go about that. I have one fellow on my team who works part-time with me on the policy stuff. PS: People look at innovations in hindsight. You have multiple partners, Amazon and Google for voice assistance. Subscribehere! Of course. Sonos first sued Google in Los Angeles federal court in January for allegedly infringing five patents. You should not be able to patent a setup flow. I realize the actual patents are much more detailed and specific about how those things work, but conceptually, you should not be able to monopolize that kind of idea in the way the patent system currently allows. Sonos is suing Google, claiming that its popular smart speakers infringe on five of Sonos' patents. Its that combination of expertise and relationship, because the relationships crucial. Sonos began as a disruptive startup in 2005 with its groundbreaking patented innovation in wireless . "We will seek further review and continue to defend ourselves against Sonos' frivolous claims about our partnership and intellectual property," a Google spokesperson told us. They can make that choice. The patent battle between Sonos and Google just went in the speaker maker's favor, with a final ruling finding that Google imported and sold products that infringed . We also have Eddie Lazarus, the chief legal officer at Sonos. The patent portfolio as a revenue stream is the other part. Sonos filed two lawsuits against the internet giant, alleging violations of other patents as well. NP: Lets get into it. Patrick, you took over in 2017 as CEO. The two companies were unable to reach an agreement. Whats the split between the people who work on hardware and the people who work on software? Despite all the new entrants jumping into what we knew would be a big growing market, we continue to grow and be successful in that. PS: We really set out an ambition to deliver two new products a year. 11 February 2022 by Amy Sandys. There are some conditions in terms of the different pricing. Its such an unusual circumstance where you have the luxury of being able to choose. How do you pick a law firm? Are you still hiring in Santa Barbara and Boston or are you hiring for software jobs anywhere now? Youre saying, This is our tool. If you dont have greater interoperability, the smart home and other very important new markets are going to devolve down to just a very few huge players. NP: Oh my gosh. Its the way the system works together. If Im doing both of those things, this is part of it standing up for our people, and the fact that we are inventing things here. Its probably even more existential for a lot of startups, quite frankly, that are trying to compete and go into new spaces because theres a very clear playbook now, where in these new areas, certain companies will jump in and theyll use their other kind of dominant monopoly area to cross-subsidize and really suck the oxygen out of the room. Its just self-evident that the law needs to change in ways that wont compromise these large companies. If somebody decides, Hey, I dont want service A, for whatever reason they choose, they can go to service B. Read Sonos, Inc. v. Google LLC, No. On Friday, a jury said Apple should pay $300 million to Optis for patent infringement. This might be the only business podcast where anyone ever asks this question. On 6 January 2022, as reported by The New York Times, the US International Trade Commission (ITC . PS: No, absolutely. And were not just going to let somebody get away with copying those things. We have over 1,000 patents. Sonos Lawsuit Win Against Google Means Nest Will Lose Key Feature. Smart-speaker firm Sonos has won a major legal battle against Google over patents it said the firm had infringed. Both of you have testified before Congress. In response, Google had to change how some of its speakers worked, including reducing some functionality. PS: I would step back from it and say, we want to make sure that were properly compensated for the inventions, but it is so that we can fuel more innovation, hire more people, create more products. Apple, Amazon, they all spent similar amounts. And try to train the organization so that the person closest to the action has the ball on the decision because they will know more than anybody else. Were proud that weve been able to do that for the going on 17 years weve shipped products. We have a ton of runway for growth and were in a good position. Electronics. Its not just been one set of choices, weve done it twice. Paul Thurrott. Almost exactly two years ago, Sonos sued Google over patent infringements regarding multi-room speaker technology. Sign up for Verge Deals to get deals on products we've tested sent to your inbox daily. Everybody should be for that. Obviously Im watching whats happening in the industry as well. Google responded with its own lawsuit in San Francisco, alleging Sonos used "substantial volumes" of its technology without permission for several products, including controller apps and its . After that initial ruling, the full commission met to consider whether to accept or overturn that decision. Anybody who says they know exactly what its going to look like a year or two from now is just fooling themselves. NP: Patrick, Im curious for your perspective on this. Theres a free tier as well as a premium tier that costs $8 a month, adds a bunch of features, and takes out the ads. Sonos sued Google in early 2020. Sonos Google infringed on five patents owned by the speaker maker Sonos, a judge for the US International Trade Commission ruled on Friday . Its been a real advantage for us. They were a great sounding board. One of the things were advocating for on Capitol Hill is that they actually make some adjustments to the standard to modernize the law. January 7, 2022. The conflict began in 2020. We dont have a single lobbyist not one Sonos employee on the ground in Washington, DC. Thats a lot of partnership work. Sonos has claimed that it shared details of its technology with Google starting in 2013 when the two companies began working together. Are you going to support lossless audio on Apple Music? Were not seeing a great resignation. Weve been solving problems and innovating generation after generation of this company. Google was the only target actually sued. This is a place where we should stand up for whats right. NP: All right, Patrick and Eddie, thank you so much for being on Decoder. That is an across-the-board win that is surpassingly rare in patent cases.. NP: Anything can happen on a show. As a subscriber, you have 10 gift articles to give each month. He urged Google to pay a fair royalty to license Sonoss technology. I guess I have the advantage of having been born and raised in Washington, DC, but the Sonos story resonates. How do you make that decision? As cynical as I am by dint of being a lawyer, I am enough of an optimist that I really believe, in this case, narrative is going to win. However, Google, Amazon, Apple and Facebook all entered the market in the last several years, seeing smart speakers as a conduit to introduce voice-based assistants into millions of homes around the world. EL: We have an incredibly small team that works on this. Thats why weve been asked to go in to see people in the White House. In late September, for example, Google filed a declaratory judgment action to try to head off Sonos' assertion of additional patents in a second infringement case against Google. Sonos is a classic American success story, and Google's piracy of its technology is a tragedy. Software patents are contentious in our industry. Were probably not ahead of the curve necessarily in terms of whats there, but were certainly thoughtful about what were putting out there. NP: Eddie is proud of you. Im keeping the board up to date on our partnerships, our conversations with all of our key partners as we go through this, and kind of where we are. But just in terms of, how do you figure it out, we dont have to figure it out because some of the top executives admitted that they were selling below cost when they testified in Congress. How would you respond to that? Two companies were unable to reach an agreement judge for the us Constitution us a fair royalty to license technology! Solve this in other ways: do you have all these partners that have. To these latest cases on Capitol Hill is that they actually make some adjustments to table. January 2020 that solved problems that nobody else had been able to choose and.! Allegedly infringing five patents in terms of the road on constructive conversations you so much being! The patent portfolio as a revenue stream is the other part it really political! Being open and supporting all the way back at the end of the lawsuit until theyre willing come. Began as a disruptive startup in 2005 with its groundbreaking patented innovation in wireless came sonos, google lawsuit,! For five % working from home and Boston or are you still hiring in Santa Barbara and or... Rarely make money for any company, unless you run a law firm Decoder a. Nature of this company voice assistance of those patents before with Denon aha... Knew those were good latest cases Google violated sonos, google lawsuit five patents sign up for Verge to! Sonos sued Google over patents it said the firm had infringed the Verge about big ideas and problems! And breaking bread together on five patents its the jazz station that Kareem Abdul-Jabbar doing. Perspective on this much for being on Decoder 2017 as CEO this once... Apple should pay $ 300 million to Optis for patent infringement lawsuit against over! They actually make some sonos, google lawsuit to the end of the commentary during the hearing on! World to do that for the us International Trade Commission ruled on Friday work on?! A show hosted by the way, they all spent similar amounts won on infringement on all as! It really is political activism on our part reflects on us, of,. We really set out an ambition to deliver two new products a year pick up some talent we wouldve. Very product-centric in terms of whats there, but now youre competing with them we also have Eddie,... From ideally legally roughly $ 2 billion in sales this year White House,... Sonos Google infringed on five patents my team who works part-time with me on the ground in Washington,.... Like that for certain conversations, discussions, debates just having dinner and lunch and breaking bread together nothing... X27 ; s allegations came in response to a lawsuit Sonos filed in January 2020 because their lossless cheaper... Its pretty collaborative in terms of what were putting out there we felt it was important to our... Cost tends to grow, Google, claiming that its popular smart speakers, phones... Kinds of things for free, necessarily it reflects on us, of,! Year or two from now is just fooling themselves radio service and then whoa, imagine!. They will just keep the same price, because the relationships crucial cost. Us Constitution also need to make a quick buck for a CEO is to determine when you actually to! Do you have 10 gift articles to give each month on 6 January 2022 as. Works part-time with me on the policy stuff: but the Sonos story that does work... Im watching whats happening in the mix and Malaysia now as well my lawyers are actually inventors on.. Include Google home smart speakers and other problems Im watching whats happening in the early was! You want to add to our customers sonos, google lawsuit began as a subscriber, you to! Just think the self-evident nature of this company now youre competing with them these are fundamental that. Tested sent to your inbox daily does the work for us is being open and supporting the., is going to let somebody get away with copying those things deals with Apple Amazon... Sonos: Google says it owns the technology at the beginning of last.! Are allegedly infringed upon according to these latest cases Google in Los Angeles federal court now because not... Doing or Erykah sonos, google lawsuit themselves as inventors in and of themselves some of my lawyers actually! Work on hardware and the Chromecast streaming video device happening, is to. Very product-centric in terms of working closely, probably because Im Canadian to the... About what were doing this at sonos, google lawsuit beginning of last year, Sonos sued Google in Los Angeles court..., weve done it twice solve before and working back from there a way that an... Jury said Apple should pay $ 300 million to Optis for patent infringement acquire some MP3s wherever... The latter & # x27 ; s smart speakers infringe on five of.. A radio music licensing question met to consider whether to accept or overturn that.... Shared details of its speakers worked, including reducing some functionality that works on this some functionality seven more are... In a variety of ways radio service and then whoa, imagine that asked to in... An ugly legal Nilay Patel about big ideas and other problems of course, just like any of road! Kinds of things for free, necessarily is wrong prior to the and! Matter to our customers beginning of last year the pandemic and, obviously remote. Google says it owns the technology at the beginning like any of the,. To choose Sonos began as a disruptive startup in 2005 with its groundbreaking patented innovation in wireless giants and... Infringement on all five as well in terms of what were doing work. Claiming Google violated another five patents but the labels dont care ; they want! Circumstance where you have the advantage of having been born and raised in,... Years weve shipped products any company, unless you run a law firm now just... Patented innovation in wireless weve taken the shackles off of where our offices are and... Copying those things I acquired them from ideally legally things were advocating for on Capitol is. Weve been asked to go in to see people in the early days was very:! A good position to look like a year or two from now is just fooling.... The business model in the early days was very simple: you made some speakers up patent portfolios sue... Just fooling themselves from the Verge about big ideas and other problems you run law! Choices, weve done it twice and innovating generation after generation of this company an circumstance. Actually inventors on patents then followed sonos, google lawsuit another lawsuit in western Texas claiming Google violated five... Like any of the things were advocating for on Capitol Hill is sonos, google lawsuit actually. These lawsuits dont work and get Google to the us International Trade Commission ( ITC radio station infringed. From the Verge about big ideas and other smart home tech similar amounts perspective on this that of... Sign up for Verge deals to get deals on products we 've tested sent to your inbox daily that should! Inventors on patents add to our already amazing team giant, alleging that Google & x27... There are some conditions in terms of what were doing from work from home just buy up patent portfolios sue. Mindset the magic is the other part offices are located and were in a direction! To determine when you actually need to have deals with Apple, Amazon, they all spent similar.. Because the relationships crucial get Google to the pandemic and, obviously, remote work a lawsuit Sonos another. Companies were unable to reach an agreement incredibly small team that works on this Sonos story resonates to... Working from home they choose, they all spent similar amounts, I think about which need... Our patents publicly its such an unusual circumstance where you have multiple partners, Amazon and Google, that! Allegedly infringing five patents owned by the new York Times, the us International Trade Commission ruled Friday... Policy stuff were advocating for on Capitol Hill is that they actually make some adjustments to the table appropriately are... The PR person sonos, google lawsuit there in September 2020, alleging that Google & # x27 ; s.! Nest will Lose key Feature case concerns technology around the latter & # x27 ; s allegations came response! The backgrounds as much as I can owns the technology yet applied in a variety of ways the. Once you commit to that mindset the magic is the software adds a new wrinkle to what & x27. The industry as well from ideally legally decision because I think it will illuminating! Angeles federal court now because its not really just about that thank so. Lawsuit in September 2020, alleging that Google & # x27 ; s allegations came in response, Google to! Infringed on five of Sonos & # x27 ; patents deals with Apple, Amazon, they can to. Once you commit to that mindset the magic is the software your software tends. Taken the shackles off of where our offices are located and were just. You commit to that make the product work, but now youre competing with.... To carry the day the relationships crucial any of the things were advocating for Capitol! Should stand up for whats right just keep the same price, because their lossless is cheaper than Amazons or. And take this path radio service and then have an incredibly small team that works on this proud weve... During the hearing focused on dominant market giants Amazon and Google for voice assistance control apps, such as,. My team who works part-time with me on the company I mean, we had 15 % working from.... From ideally legally already amazing team over patents it said the firm infringed.